Sports card comps

Search graded singles, scan PSA grade bands, and review eBay sold history without digging through noisy raw listings.

Tip: include the grader and grade in the search, or use the fields for tighter comps.

97 highest-value 2026 card results eBay sold-history lookup is unavailable; showing local database results only.
Any graderAny gradeNo minNo max
Playerwillie maysModebroad player scan

Card show read

Fast buying context from the sold history below.

Buy target$11270% of median comp
Median comp$160317 sold comps
Last 3 avg$263Recent tape
LiquidityLiquid259 in 30d · 308 in 90d
FreshnessLatest 2d agoLatest $365
RiskWide spread$1 to $20,000

eBay sold history

Public sold-listing history with direct links to the original eBay listings.

SalePriceDateVenueType
1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 6 HOF GOAT Centered$365Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1957 Topps Willie Mays #10 PSA 2 - New York Giants - Hall of Fame$211Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 - PSA 5$215Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 Topps WILLIE MAYS #200 HOF San Francisco Giants PSA 3$85Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1965 Topps Willie Mays #250 SGC 4$150Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
MICKEY MANTLE WILLIE MAYS AUTOGRAPHED LITHO MATTED TO 8x10 scoreboard coa$104Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1951 World Series Program Yankees Giants Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Rookie VG$85Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Topps Manager Dream #18 PSA 3 HOF Baseball Card$200Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1963 Major League Baseball Magazine Featuring Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays$1Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays MLB Card$84Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1954 TOPPS #90 WILLIE MAYS SGC 4.5$688Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 3 VG San Francisco Giants HOF Vintage$70Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
🔥🔥1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #250 San Francisco Giants HOF PSA 2 GOOD 🔥🔥$72Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS 1966 TOPPS PSA 2$42Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays PSA 4$399Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Super Stars Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Harmon Killebrew #490 PSA 1$129Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1993 Upper Deck B.A.T. Triple-Folders - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #137$3Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps - Willie Mays San Francisco Giants #5 PSA EX-MT 6$717Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1965 Topps #250 Willie Mays - San Francisco Giants PSA 6.5$575Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps HOF Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #18 Baseball Card No Creases$100Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$150Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 Topps Checklists (4), VG, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, F. Robinson, Marichal$21Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays Giants 1956 Topps #130 PSA 8 AKA PSA 7 Gray Back PLEASE READ$2,499Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Harmon Killebrew #490 SGC 4.5 VG-EX+$188Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1974 Topps Willie Mays '73 World Series Game 2 #473 PSA 7 Baseball MLB$54Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF Gray Back PSA 4 VG-EX$500Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays Giants 1956 Topps #130 PSA 8 AKA PSA 7 Gray Back PLEASE READ$2,649Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 BGS 7 NM. Centered & Eye Appeal$525Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA (AA) Authentic Altered$26Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays Gray Back SGC 4.5$500Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 TOPPS #18 MANAGERS DREAM MICKEY MANTLE & WILLIE MAYS PSA 2.5 Mick's MVP YR$170Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream (Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays)$132Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
April 1963 Baseball magazine Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays on the cover, no ML$33Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1963 Topps #300 Willie Mays SGC 6 EX-NEAR MINT HOF Actively accepting consignments! Listings within 2 days$375Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron #18$89Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
MICKEY MANTLE - WILLIE MAYS - DUKE SNIDER Rare GYPSY OAK Wooden Trading Card$20Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps #490 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Harmon Killebrew Super Stars EX+$170Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS 1971 Topps #600 SGC 2 Good San Francisco Giants$40Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 4$125Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Super Stars Harmon Killebrew Willie Mays Mickey Mantle #490 PSA 7$425Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 Topps Willie Mays Baseball Card #200 SGC VG+ 3.5$75Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE & WILLIE MAYS (MANAGERS' DREAM) #18 SGC 1.5$135Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays 1970 Topps PSA 3 VG #600 San Francisco Giants$64Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures - 62' Topps Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #100$5Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 SGC 1$62Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1982 Topps Limited Edition K-Mart COMPLETE SET (44) Mickey Mantle Willie Mays PROBSTEIN is actively accepting consignments!!! Brand$1Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers’ Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays SGC 6.5 EX-NM+$649Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Willie Mays #300 PSA 2 Good Vintage Giants HOF Legend!$108Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 PSA 2 San Francisco Giants$120Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS STAND-UP WILLIE MAYS SGC 2$225Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1961 Topps # 150 Willie Mays PSA 4 Vg-Ex$125Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1969 Topps Willie Mays #190 SGC 4.5 Giants$125Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Mickey Mantle Collection Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #40$5Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream (Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays)$150Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays 2026 Leaf Seasons In The Sun Let's Play 2 LP-17$120Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 SGC 7 NM$777Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Topps - Willie Mays #200 PSA 1.5$57Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 6 Giants$222Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$150Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays -$110Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays Gray Back PSA 4 #130 Consign with us! Sign Up & Get Started @ ratedrips-com$429Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1966 Topps Willie Mays #1 Giants PSA 2.5$59Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
GRADED 1963 Topps #300 WILLIE MAYS PSA 4 VG-EX San Francisco Giants ** L@@K **$173Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1952 Bowman Willie Mays #218 PSA 5 EX HOF Beautiful Registration and Color$4,150Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$199Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron #18 Elston Howard, John...$154Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays 1956 56 Topps #130 Gray Back New York Giants SGC 4.5$500Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays PSA 4$350Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back Card (PSA 1)$180Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps: #130 Willie Mays Gray Back MBA 4 VG-EX Now Actively Accepting$636Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1955 Topps #194 Willie Mays SGC 3 VG Nice Color$625Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays 2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures by Andy Friedman #100$6Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron In Back #18$178Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Yankees Giants HOF$149Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1955 TOPPS #194 WILLIE MAYS HOF SGC 2.5$400Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1954 Topps - Willie Mays #90$285Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays Giants 1961 Topps #150 PSA 8 NM-MT$1,999Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1957 Willie Mays Topps BGS 4 #10$250Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1954 Topps - Willie Mays #90 PSA 2-Beautiful Card$479Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1963 Fleer Willie Mays San Francisco Giants #5 Baseball Card SGC 2 rare$60Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 Managers Dream VG-EX+ 4.5 GMA$245Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 HOF$107Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps -Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Elston Howard #33 1962 Topps;$4Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays PSA 4 VG-EX Yankees Giants$275Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1959 Topps Baseball #50 Willie Mays PSA 4$300Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Topps x Mickey Mantle Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays / Harmon Killebrew #40 -$3Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 SGC 1$94Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps: #130 Willie Mays Gray Back MBA 5 EX Now Actively Accepting$683Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays HOF two creases$100Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays SGC 3 VG Managers Dream Yankees Giants$140Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1959 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 1 *130$89Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps #490 Super Stars Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Killebrew PSA 3 VG HOF$190Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE & WILLIE MAYS (MANAGERS' DREAM) #18 PSA 4$210Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Topps x Mickey Mantle #29 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Yankees$8Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays PSA EX 5 *6257$349Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays Killebrew #490 PSA 5 ST$299Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays Gray Back PSA 3 VG GotBaseballCards-PSA/SGC Grading + eBay Consignment$330Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Willie Mays Topps BGS 5.5 #200$250Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps High # Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Harmon Killebrew #490 PSA 3$175Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1955 Bowman 184 Willie Mays PSA 2 157218760 Quickest To List & Payout Consign at pcsportscards-com$275Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Manager's Dream card #18 Willie Mays / Mickey Mantle$110Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 2.5 Good + Centered! Say Hey Kid!$335Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 7$2,900Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 2.5$87Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays #100 ()$4Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF Gray Back PSA 4 VG-EX$420Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays HOF$90Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$150Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1969 Topps MLB Baseball 190 Willie Mays PSA 1 San Francisco Giants$25Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle - Willie Mays - 1962 Topps Managers Dream #18 - HOF - PSA 5$395Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1966 Topps - Willie Mays #1 PSA 1.5. Hall Of Fame Giants. $35Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$175Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 TOPPS HARMON KILLEBREW - WILLIE MAYS - MICKEY MANTLE #490 - PSA 2$134Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps #50 Willie Mays SGC 4$95Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF Gray Back PSA 4 VG-EX$468Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps - Mickey Mantle Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, #33$3Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1956 Willie Mays New York Giants #130 Gray Back PSA 3.5$569Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays #18 VG+$75Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1961 Topps #150 Willie Mays SGC 4$100Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #100$11Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 8$5,500Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 1.5 Nicely Centered$240Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays W/Hank Aaron Elston Howard Background$150Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1973 Topps Willie Mays #305 PSA 5$65Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays - Fair *crease*$76Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$175Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #200 SGC 2.5$60Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps #490 Super Stars w/ Willie Mays Mickey Mantle HOF SGC 2$98Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Baseball Managers' Dream #18 Card$125Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANT #51 WILLIE MAYS SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS HOF VGEX SURFACE WRINKLE$162Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 SGC 1.5$125Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays Gray Back PSA 5 (67)$800Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures by Andy Friedman Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays$3Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays Killebrew #490 PSA 5 ST$299Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490. TRIMMED!!$75Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays (Trimmed)$208Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays PSA 7, Well Centered! 😍$395Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #300 Willie Mays - VG$48Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays #150 PSA 1.5 FR$65Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays Killebrew #490 PSA 5 ST$299Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays 1962 Topps VINTAGE MANAGER'S DREAM #18 SGC 3.5👀⚾️🔥$200Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle/ Willie Mays #18 - PSA 3$180Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 Gray Back New York Giants Baseball Card$250Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 HOF$72Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
New York Yankees 1962 World Series Game 4 Giants Mickey Mantle Willie Mays$90Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps #18 Yankees Giants MS4$100Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays - Excellent/NM Condition - SF Giants - FBD$190Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1959 Topps - Willie Mays #50 - SGC 3.5$175Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1968 High # Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Harmon Killebrew Super Stars #490$235Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS SGC 3 "40" 1956 TOPPS BASEBALL #130 GRAY BACK 015$288Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1996 Topps Mickey Mantle Commemorative Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, #33$4Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Yankees Giants #18 PSA 3 Baseball$160Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 3$400Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1956 #130 Willie Mays New York Giants Baseball Card Gray Back Base$401Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS PSA 4 1956 TOPPS BASEBALL #130 GRAY BACK 3416$431Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Harmon Killebrew Willie Mays Mickey Mantle #490 PSA 9 MINT LOW POP$4,000Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1961 Willie Mays #150 San Francisco Giants PSA 1 Base Set Card$50Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 Managers' Dream MLB Baseball 1996$5Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays VG Line Near Arm$73Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps #490 Super Stars Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Killebrew PSA 3 VG HOF$190Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays - Fair *crease*$75Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps 130 Willie Mays Gray Back PSA 1 157872154 Quickest To List & Payout Consign at pcsportscards-com$225Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps - Willie Mays #5 - PSA 3$190Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #300 Willie Mays HOF San Francisco Giants PSA 8 NM-MT HIGH END$20,000Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS HOF #200 - SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS - PSA$45Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps Vintage Base Set 1956 Willie Mays #130 New York Giants MLB Gray Back$100Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANTS #51 WILLIE MAYS GIANTS HOF SGC 6 Expert eBay listing since 2003:Consign your best today!$180Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1951 MICKEY MANTLE ORIGINAL NEWSPAPER SCRAPBOOK TOPPS RC PHOTO WILLIE MAYS 1952$25Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 PSA 6$431Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1954 Bowman #89 Willie Mays (HOF) NY Giants SGC 1$180Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays (HOF) PSA 5 ~ Gray Back ~ Well Centered$950Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 EX$160Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 TOPPS #490 MICKEY MANTLE WILLIE MAYS SHARP 562735 (KYCARDS)$488Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Manager's Dream Willie Mays Mickey Mantle SGC 3 VG CENTERED$220Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays$105Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps #150 Willie Mays SGC 1$45Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Game Complete Set Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Roberto Clemente$185Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays (HOF) #130 - Gray Back PSA 5 - Just$890Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back$225Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps Super Stars Harmon Killebrew Willie Mays Mickey Mantle #490 PSA 6$380Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANTS #51 WILLIE MAYS PSA 5$181Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays PSA 5.5$500Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 3$160Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers Dream #18 * Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays * PSA 6$535Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1956 Willie Mays #130 Gray Back New York Giants PSA 2$269Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream (Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays) Creased Corners$53Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps #33 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays Mickey Mantle$4Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 3 VG New York Giants$370Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps MICKEY MANTLE #490⭐SUPER STARS⭐WILLIE MAYS💥SHARP CLEAN VISUAL🚨BACK$80Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays, Hank Aaron #31 Gray Back; PSA 6$985Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays PSA 5$450Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron #18 Elston Howard, John...$160Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays HOF (LOOK)$100Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps #490 Super Stars Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Killebrew SGC 5.5 HOF$290Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays SGC 5 EX AD991$800Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back$178Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51 EX$166Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
3728786 Willie Mays 1957 Topps #10 SGC 1.5 Quickest To List & Payout Consign at pcsportscards-com$120Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS #150 WILLIE MAYS SGC 1.5$59Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps #5 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2 (MC) Good$125Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
MANAGERS' DREAM Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Yankees Giants MLB Baseball Card #18$120Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 SGC 4.5$250Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490$155Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1961 Topps - Willie Mays #150 - PSA 4$135Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 6$1,133Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps #33 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays Reprints Finest$6Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps High # Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Harmon Killebrew #490 SGC 1.5$110Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays San Francisco Giants HOF Gray Back PSA 3 VG$307Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
NY Yankees Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew TCMA 4 x 6 1984 -27 Brand$28Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 #200 Willie Mays PSA 4$110Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
56’ Topps Willie Mays, Hank Aaron #31 Gray Back; Background Photo is Willie Mays$101Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Mickey Reprints Finest RF5$1Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 MLB$85Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 COLOR PHOTO OF WILLIE MAYS MICKEY MANTLE DUKE SNIDER COA$45Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps Mickey Mantle Reprints #33, 1962 Managers Dream w/ Willie Mays$3Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays 1997 Topps - Mickey Mantle Reprints insert #33 (NM)$3Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps SUPER STARS Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays / Killebrew #490 PSA 8.5 HOF$1,780Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Topps x Mickey Mantle Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays / Harmon Killebrew #40 -$6Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays New York Giants HOF Gray Back SGC 84 NM 7$1,602Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS 1956 TOPPS BASEBALL GRAY BACK #130 NEW YORK GIANTS PSA 4 Q3562$430Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Topps X Mickey Mantle Collection - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #29$3Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1962 Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays Base Set MLB$134Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 TOPPS # 18 MICKEY MANTLE WILLIE MAYS SGC 3.5 VG+ 560748 (KYCARDS)$155Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays 1956 Topps # 130 Gray Back PSA 9 Mint OC$5,500Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1968 Topps - High # Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Harmon Killebrew #490 pSAA 2 GD$145Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Manager’s Dream Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays SGC 4 HOF Awesome!!$190Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 Topps 2nd & 3rd Series Checklists Mickey Mantle Willie Mays # 103 & 191$16Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays PSA 3 VG Vintage Giants HOF Gray Back$385Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1965 Topps Willie Mays #250 (GIANTS) PSA 4$180Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants card #51 Willie Mays San Francisco Giants HOF SGC 2 VG$140Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures #100 Canvas Stock - Mickey Mantle Willie/Mays$39Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Venezuela Manager’s Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 1 NICE!$2,000Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays GRAY BACK SGC 5 EX$675Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 - PSA 4.5 Gray Back$600Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back$357Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1959 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 4 VERY GOOD - EXCELLENT HOF Consign with us! Listings within 2 business days!$219Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1967 Topps - Willie Mays #200 SGC 1 San Francisco Giants Vintage$40Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 TOPPS #130 WILLIE MAYS, GRAY BACK - PSA 5 EX (SVSC) NEWLY$1,100Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 Gray back (Fair/Good condition)$134Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 New York Giants Gray Back SGC 1.5$260Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays New York Giants Gray Back SGC 3$320Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1962 Managers' Dream #18 Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays PSA 7$755Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1996 Topps Mickey Mantle Commemorative Set - Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays #33$2Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps #5 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2 (MC) Good$125Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps baseball #18 vintage Managers Dream$79Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 1962 Baseball Card$52Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Yankees Giants Vintage$61Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 MBA 5 EX$185Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
4759189 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream SGC 2 Quickest To List & Payout Consign at pcsportscards-com$87Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures - 1962 Topps Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #100$3Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 3$394Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream (Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays)$119Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps Managers' Dream Vintage Baseball Card #18$168Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #100$13Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Topps 200 Willie Mays PSA 1.5 152807684 Quickest To List & Payout Consign at pcsportscards-com$102Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers Dream Mickey Mantle & Willie Mays PSA 3 Very Good$170Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Duke Snider Autographed Perez Steele Great Moments JSA$1,596Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Baseball Managers' Dream #18 Card$100Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps - Mickey Mantle Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Elston Howard...$2Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps #18 Managers' Dream (Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays) Creased$66Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Venezuelan Mngrs Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 Spanish Back$885Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps Managers' Dream Vintage Baseball Card #18$150Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps - Mickey Mantle Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Elston Howard...$4Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1997 Topps - Mickey Mantle Reprints Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #33$3Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1951 Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1st World Series PSA Ticket Joe DiMaggio Last HR$1,499Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 1$92Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 4$525Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays #18$70Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51$115Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays #51 SGC 5.5$210Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
Mickey Mantle Willie Mays 1962 Topps Managers’ Dream 18 SGC 3 Giants Yankees VG$108Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 2$123Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 SGC 2 GRAY BACK GOOD$300Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - #51 Willie Mays Willie's Greatest Day- Large Card$200Aug 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51$120Aug 5, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays 1964 Topps Giants #51$180Aug 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANTS #51 WILLIE MAYS GIANTS HOF PSA 9 Get unbeatable industry-low consignment rates at 4SC!$2,850Aug 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays PSA 7$340Aug 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1953 Topps #244 Willie Mays SGC 1 Vintage SP HOF Baseball Card (6034)$1,389Jul 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays#51 PSA 3 VG -RV$120Jul 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51$111Jul 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANT #51 WILLIE MAYS HOF OF THE SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS PSA 8 NM-MINT$545Jul 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 topps Giants #51 Willie Mays, SGC 5 !!!!$149Jul 28, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays 1956 Topps Gray back PSA 2 #130 New York Giants$360Jul 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays #51 San Francisco Giants MLB Near Mint/Mint$175Jul 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays SGC 7 NEAR MINT HOF Consign with us! Listings within 2 business days!$208Jul 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 TOPPS GIANTS #51 WILLIE MAYS PSA 6$175Jul 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays #51 Short Print “SHARP” READ!! 🔥$200Jul 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1954 Topps #90 Willie Mays SGC 3 VG Vintage HOF New York Giants Baseball Card$527Jul 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 TOPPS GRAY BACK #130 WILLIE MAYS SGC 3$328Jul 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants 51 Willie Mays in Excellent Condition$35Jul 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1970 Topps WILLIE MAYS #600 SGC 4.5 (VG/EX+) HOF Giants BASEBALL CARD$75Jul 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Willie Mays Topps Giants Baseball Card #51 PSA 4 *San Francisco* short prin$355Jul 14, 2026eBaySold listing
Willie Mays credit card w/related autographed check. PSA/DNA GEM MINT 10$549Jul 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1955 BOWMAN WILLIE MAYS #184 SGC 2$190Jul 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays #51 San Francisco Giants HOF EX-MT NICE CLEAN CARD$200Jul 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants #51 Willie Mays PSA 8 NM-MT *San Francisco Giants*$432Jul 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51$115Jul 5, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS 1964 TOPPS GIANTS BASEBALL #51 GIANTS Q5547$107Jul 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Giants - Willie Mays #51 Oversized Card Set$115Jul 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #250 SGC 2$65Jun 28, 2026eBaySold listing
WILLIE MAYS 1958 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #5 SGC 6 EX-NM SF GIANTS HOF$575Jun 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 Topps #5 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2 (MC) Good HOF Giants All Star Beautiful Card$91Jun 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1972 TOPPS #49 WILLIE MAYS PSA 1$30Jun 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1955 Bowman Willie Mays #184 PSA 2 (MC) Good$200Jun 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps #130 Willie Mays Gray Back SGC Authentic$185Jun 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130 Gray Back PSA 1 Poor Condition New York Giants HOF$165Jun 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 PSA 2$100Jun 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1960's Yankee Stadium Postcard Mickey Mantle Willie Mays SGC 4.5$121Jun 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1958 TOPPS BASEBALL #5 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2 (MC) GOOD JUST BACK FROM PSA$124May 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1957 Topps Set-Break # 10 Willie Mays SGC 6 EX NM Now Actively Accepting$510May 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1953 Topps # 244 Willie Mays (Short Print) SGC 3 ICONIC CARD$2,011Apr 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1964 Topps Willie Mays Signed Baseball Card #150 PSA 5 DNA Certified 9 Auto HOF$3,288Mar 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1957 TOPPS #10 WILLIE MAYS NEW YORK GIANTS BASEBALL CARD SGC 5 EX$500Feb 21, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures #100 MICKEY MANTLE & WILLIE MAYS “Managers’ Dream”$5Feb 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1957 TOPPS Baseball Card #10 WILLIE MAYS HOF New York Giants SGC 5$595Feb 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1956 Topps Willie Mays PSA 7 (MC) Near Mint #130 Gray Back$775Feb 3, 2026eBaySold listing

Matched cards

Grouped by slab, with the current observed sale band split into scan-friendly columns.

1962 Topps · PSA 8

1962 Topps Willie Mays #300 PSA 8

1962 Topps #300

Highest 2026 sale: $20,000 on Aug 26, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$20,000
Max price
$20,000
Highest 2026 sale
$20,000
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps - Willie Mays · PSA 8

1956 Topps - Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 8

1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $5,500 on Aug 31, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$5,500
Max price
$5,500
Highest 2026 sale
$5,500
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1952 Bowman · PSA 5

1952 Bowman Willie Mays #218 PSA 5

1952 Bowman #218

Highest 2026 sale: $4,150 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 5
Min price
$4,150
Max price
$4,150
Highest 2026 sale
$4,150
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · PSA 9

1968 Topps LOW #490 PSA 9

1968 Topps #490

Highest 2026 sale: $4,000 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$4,000
Max price
$4,000
Highest 2026 sale
$4,000
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps Willie Mays · PSA 7

1956 Topps Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 7

1956 Topps Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $2,900 on Sep 2, 2026

Grade
PSA 7
Min price
$2,900
Max price
$2,900
Highest 2026 sale
$2,900
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · PSA 8

1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 PSA 8

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $2,649 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$2,499
Max price
$2,649
Highest 2026 sale
$2,649
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · PSA 8

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 8

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $1,999 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$1,999
Max price
$1,999
Highest 2026 sale
$1,999
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1953 Topps · SGC 1

1953 Topps Willie Mays #244 SGC 1

1953 Topps #244

Highest 2026 sale: $1,389 on Jul 31, 2026

Grade
SGC 1
Min price
$1,389
Max price
$1,389
Highest 2026 sale
$1,389
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 TOPPS · PSA 5

1956 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS GRAY BACK #130 PSA 5

1956 TOPPS #130

Highest 2026 sale: $1,100 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 5
Min price
$800
Max price
$1,100
Highest 2026 sale
$1,100
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps Managers' Dream · SGC 5

1962 Topps Managers' Dream Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays #18 SGC 5

1962 Topps Managers' Dream #18

Highest 2026 sale: $800 on Aug 22, 2026

Grade
SGC 5
Min price
$800
Max price
$800
Highest 2026 sale
$800
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · PSA 7

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays #18 PSA 7

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $755 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 7
Min price
$755
Max price
$755
Highest 2026 sale
$755
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1958 Topps · PSA 6

1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 PSA 6

1958 Topps #5

Highest 2026 sale: $717 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 6
Min price
$717
Max price
$717
Highest 2026 sale
$717
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1954 TOPPS · SGC 4.5

1954 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #90 SGC 4.5

1954 TOPPS #90

Highest 2026 sale: $688 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$688
Max price
$688
Highest 2026 sale
$688
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 6.5

1962 Topps EX-NM #18 SGC 6.5

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $649 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
SGC 6.5
Min price
$649
Max price
$649
Highest 2026 sale
$649
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1955 Topps · SGC 3

1955 Topps Willie Mays #194 SGC 3

1955 Topps #194

Highest 2026 sale: $625 on Sep 5, 2026

Grade
SGC 3
Min price
$625
Max price
$625
Highest 2026 sale
$625
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1965 Topps · PSA 6.5

1965 Topps Willie Mays #250 PSA 6.5

1965 Topps #250

Highest 2026 sale: $575 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 6.5
Min price
$575
Max price
$575
Highest 2026 sale
$575
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps Managers Dream · PSA 6

1962 Topps Managers Dream Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays #18 PSA 6

1962 Topps Managers Dream #18

Highest 2026 sale: $535 on Aug 23, 2026

Grade
PSA 6
Min price
$535
Max price
$535
Highest 2026 sale
$535
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1960 Topps · BGS 7

1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 BGS 7

1960 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $525 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
BGS 7
Min price
$525
Max price
$525
Highest 2026 sale
$525
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps - Willie Mays · PSA 4

1956 Topps - Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 4

1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $525 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$429
Max price
$525
Highest 2026 sale
$525
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · SGC 4.5

1956 Topps Willie Mays Gray Back #130 SGC 4.5

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $500 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$500
Max price
$500
Highest 2026 sale
$500
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · PSA 4

1956 Topps VG-EX #130 PSA 4

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $500 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$420
Max price
$500
Highest 2026 sale
$500
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1954 Topps · PSA 2

1954 Topps Willie Mays #90 PSA 2

1954 Topps #90

Highest 2026 sale: $479 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$479
Max price
$479
Highest 2026 sale
$479
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1955 TOPPS · SGC 2.5

1955 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #194 SGC 2.5

1955 TOPPS #194

Highest 2026 sale: $400 on Sep 5, 2026

Grade
SGC 2.5
Min price
$400
Max price
$400
Highest 2026 sale
$400
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps - Willie Mays · PSA 3

1956 Topps - Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 3

1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $400 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$330
Max price
$400
Highest 2026 sale
$400
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1958 Topps · PSA 4

1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 PSA 4

1958 Topps #5

Highest 2026 sale: $399 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$350
Max price
$399
Highest 2026 sale
$399
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · PSA 5

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle - Willie Mays #18 PSA 5

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $395 on Sep 1, 2026

Grade
PSA 5
Min price
$395
Max price
$395
Highest 2026 sale
$395
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1964 Topps Giants · PSA 7

1964 Topps Giants Willie Mays #51 PSA 7

1964 Topps Giants #51

Highest 2026 sale: $395 on Aug 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 7
Min price
$340
Max price
$395
Highest 2026 sale
$395
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · PSA 3

1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 PSA 3

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $385 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$385
Max price
$385
Highest 2026 sale
$385
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1963 Topps · SGC 6

1963 Topps Willie Mays #300 SGC 6

1963 Topps #300

Highest 2026 sale: $375 on Sep 8, 2026

Grade
SGC 6
Min price
$375
Max price
$375
Highest 2026 sale
$375
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays · PSA 3

1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 3

1956 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $370 on Aug 23, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$370
Max price
$370
Highest 2026 sale
$370
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · PSA 6

1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 6

1968 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $365 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 6
Min price
$365
Max price
$365
Highest 2026 sale
$365
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · PSA 2

1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 PSA 2

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $360 on Jul 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$360
Max price
$360
Highest 2026 sale
$360
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1959 Topps Baseball · PSA 4

1959 Topps Baseball Willie Mays #50 PSA 4

1959 Topps Baseball #50

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$300
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps · SGC 2

1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 SGC 2

1956 Topps #130

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Aug 9, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$300
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · PSA 4

1962 Topps VG-EX PSA 4

1962 Topps

Highest 2026 sale: $275 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$275
Max price
$275
Highest 2026 sale
$275
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1957 Topps · BGS 4

1957 Topps Willie Mays #10 BGS 4

1957 Topps #10

Highest 2026 sale: $250 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
BGS 4
Min price
$250
Max price
$250
Highest 2026 sale
$250
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1960 Topps · BGS 5.5

1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 BGS 5.5

1960 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $250 on Sep 3, 2026

Grade
BGS 5.5
Min price
$250
Max price
$250
Highest 2026 sale
$250
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1964 TOPPS · SGC 2

1964 TOPPS STAND-UP WILLIE MAYS SGC 2

1964 TOPPS

Highest 2026 sale: $225 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$225
Max price
$225
Highest 2026 sale
$225
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1964 Topps · PSA 6

1964 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 6

1964 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $222 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 6
Min price
$222
Max price
$222
Highest 2026 sale
$222
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 3

1962 Topps VG CENTERED #18 SGC 3

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $220 on Aug 25, 2026

Grade
SGC 3
Min price
$220
Max price
$220
Highest 2026 sale
$220
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1959 Topps · PSA 4

1959 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 4

1959 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $219 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$219
Max price
$219
Highest 2026 sale
$219
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · PSA 5

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 5

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $215 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 5
Min price
$215
Max price
$215
Highest 2026 sale
$215
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1957 Topps · PSA 2

1957 Topps Willie Mays #10 PSA 2

1957 Topps #10

Highest 2026 sale: $211 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$211
Max price
$211
Highest 2026 sale
$211
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1962 Topps · PSA 3

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 3

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$200
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 3.5

1962 Topps VINTAGE MANAGER'S DREAM #18 SGC 3.5

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Aug 28, 2026

Grade
SGC 3.5
Min price
$200
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1955 Bowman · PSA 2

1955 Bowman Willie Mays #184 PSA 2

1955 Bowman #184

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Jun 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$200
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1958 Topps · PSA 3

1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 PSA 3

1958 Topps #5

Highest 2026 sale: $190 on Aug 26, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$190
Max price
$190
Highest 2026 sale
$190
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1955 BOWMAN · SGC 2

1955 BOWMAN WILLIE MAYS #184 SGC 2

1955 BOWMAN #184

Highest 2026 sale: $190 on Jul 10, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$190
Max price
$190
Highest 2026 sale
$190
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · SGC 4.5

1968 Topps Mickey Mantle/Willie Mays/Harmon Killebrew #490 SGC 4.5

1968 Topps #490

Highest 2026 sale: $188 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$188
Max price
$188
Highest 2026 sale
$188
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1954 Bowman · SGC 1

1954 Bowman Willie Mays HOF NY #89 SGC 1

1954 Bowman #89

Highest 2026 sale: $180 on Aug 25, 2026

Grade
SGC 1
Min price
$180
Max price
$180
Highest 2026 sale
$180
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1965 Topps · PSA 4

1965 Topps Willie Mays #250 PSA 4

1965 Topps #250

Highest 2026 sale: $180 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$180
Max price
$180
Highest 2026 sale
$180
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1956 Topps - Willie Mays · PSA 1

1956 Topps - Willie Mays Gray Back #130 PSA 1

1956 Topps - Willie Mays #130

Highest 2026 sale: $180 on Sep 5, 2026

Grade
PSA 1
Min price
$165
Max price
$180
Highest 2026 sale
$180
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1959 Topps · SGC 3.5

1959 Topps Willie Mays #50 SGC 3.5

1959 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $175 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
SGC 3.5
Min price
$175
Max price
$175
Highest 2026 sale
$175
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1963 Topps · PSA 4

1963 Topps WILLIE MAYS #300 PSA 4

1963 Topps #300

Highest 2026 sale: $173 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$173
Max price
$173
Highest 2026 sale
$173
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 TOPPS · PSA 2.5

1962 TOPPS Mick's MVP YR #18 PSA 2.5

1962 TOPPS #18

Highest 2026 sale: $170 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 2.5
Min price
$170
Max price
$170
Highest 2026 sale
$170
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · PSA 3

1962 Topps Very Good #18 PSA 3

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $170 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$170
Max price
$170
Highest 2026 sale
$170
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1962 Topps Topps · PSA 3

1962 Topps Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 PSA 3

1962 Topps Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $160 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$160
Max price
$160
Highest 2026 sale
$160
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 TOPPS · SGC 3.5

1962 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE WILLIE MAYS #18 SGC 3.5

1962 TOPPS #18

Highest 2026 sale: $155 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
SGC 3.5
Min price
$155
Max price
$155
Highest 2026 sale
$155
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1965 Topps · SGC 4

1965 Topps Willie Mays #250 SGC 4

1965 Topps #250

Highest 2026 sale: $150 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
SGC 4
Min price
$150
Max price
$150
Highest 2026 sale
$150
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 3

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 SGC 3

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $140 on Sep 3, 2026

Grade
SGC 3
Min price
$140
Max price
$140
Highest 2026 sale
$140
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · PSA 4

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 4

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $135 on Aug 21, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$125
Max price
$135
Highest 2026 sale
$135
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1958 Topps · PSA 2

1958 Topps WILLIE MAYS #5 PSA 2

1958 Topps #5

Highest 2026 sale: $125 on Aug 21, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$91
Max price
$125
Highest 2026 sale
$125
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · PSA 4

1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 4

1968 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $125 on Sep 8, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$125
Max price
$125
Highest 2026 sale
$125
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1969 Topps · SGC 4.5

1969 Topps Willie Mays #190 SGC 4.5

1969 Topps #190

Highest 2026 sale: $125 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$125
Max price
$125
Highest 2026 sale
$125
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1960 Stadium · SGC 4.5

1960 Stadium s Yankee SGC 4.5

1960 Stadium

Highest 2026 sale: $121 on Jun 9, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$121
Max price
$121
Highest 2026 sale
$121
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1960 Topps · PSA 2

1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 PSA 2

1960 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $120 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$100
Max price
$120
Highest 2026 sale
$120
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1957 Topps · SGC 1.5

1957 Topps Willie Mays #10 SGC 1.5

1957 Topps #10

Highest 2026 sale: $120 on Aug 22, 2026

Grade
SGC 1.5
Min price
$120
Max price
$120
Highest 2026 sale
$120
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1967 · PSA 4

1967 Willie Mays #200 PSA 4

1967 #200

Highest 2026 sale: $110 on Aug 20, 2026

Grade
PSA 4
Min price
$110
Max price
$110
Highest 2026 sale
$110
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 3

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays SGC 3

1962 Topps

Highest 2026 sale: $108 on Aug 10, 2026

Grade
SGC 3
Min price
$108
Max price
$108
Highest 2026 sale
$108
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · PSA 2

1962 Topps Willie Mays #300 PSA 2

1962 Topps #300

Highest 2026 sale: $108 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$108
Max price
$108
Highest 2026 sale
$108
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · SGC 4

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 SGC 4

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $100 on Aug 31, 2026

Grade
SGC 4
Min price
$100
Max price
$100
Highest 2026 sale
$100
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · SGC 4

1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 SGC 4

1968 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $95 on Sep 1, 2026

Grade
SGC 4
Min price
$95
Max price
$95
Highest 2026 sale
$95
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1958 Topps · SGC 1

1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 SGC 1

1958 Topps #5

Highest 2026 sale: $94 on Sep 3, 2026

Grade
SGC 1
Min price
$94
Max price
$94
Highest 2026 sale
$94
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1959 Topps · PSA 1

1959 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 1

1959 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $89 on Sep 3, 2026

Grade
PSA 1
Min price
$89
Max price
$89
Highest 2026 sale
$89
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · PSA 2.5

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 2.5

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $87 on Sep 2, 2026

Grade
PSA 2.5
Min price
$87
Max price
$87
Highest 2026 sale
$87
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1962 Topps · SGC 2

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays #18 SGC 2

1962 Topps #18

Highest 2026 sale: $87 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$87
Max price
$87
Highest 2026 sale
$87
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1967 Topps · PSA 3

1967 Topps WILLIE MAYS #200 PSA 3

1967 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $85 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$85
Max price
$85
Highest 2026 sale
$85
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1967 Topps · SGC 3.5

1967 Topps Willie Mays #200 SGC 3.5

1967 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $75 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
SGC 3.5
Min price
$75
Max price
$75
Highest 2026 sale
$75
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1970 Topps · SGC 4.5

1970 Topps WILLIE MAYS #600 SGC 4.5

1970 Topps #600

Highest 2026 sale: $75 on Jul 14, 2026

Grade
SGC 4.5
Min price
$75
Max price
$75
Highest 2026 sale
$75
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS · PSA 2

1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS San Francisco #250 PSA 2

1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #250

Highest 2026 sale: $72 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$72
Max price
$72
Highest 2026 sale
$72
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1968 Topps · PSA 3

1968 Topps Willie Mays #50 PSA 3

1968 Topps #50

Highest 2026 sale: $70 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$70
Max price
$70
Highest 2026 sale
$70
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1973 Topps · PSA 5

1973 Topps Willie Mays #305 PSA 5

1973 Topps #305

Highest 2026 sale: $65 on Aug 31, 2026

Grade
PSA 5
Min price
$65
Max price
$65
Highest 2026 sale
$65
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
PSA 1.5

Willie Mays #150 PSA 1.5

#150

Highest 2026 sale: $65 on Aug 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 1.5
Min price
$65
Max price
$65
Highest 2026 sale
$65
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1965 TOPPS · SGC 2

1965 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #250 SGC 2

1965 TOPPS #250

Highest 2026 sale: $65 on Jun 28, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$65
Max price
$65
Highest 2026 sale
$65
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1970 Topps · PSA 3

1970 Topps Willie Mays #600 PSA 3

1970 Topps #600

Highest 2026 sale: $64 on Sep 7, 2026

Grade
PSA 3
Min price
$64
Max price
$64
Highest 2026 sale
$64
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Baseball · 1963 Fleer · SGC 2

1963 Fleer Willie Mays #5 SGC 2

1963 Fleer #5

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1967 TOPPS · SGC 2.5

1967 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #200 SGC 2.5

1967 TOPPS #200

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 30, 2026

Grade
SGC 2.5
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1966 Topps · PSA 2.5

1966 Topps Willie Mays #1 PSA 2.5

1966 Topps #1

Highest 2026 sale: $59 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 2.5
Min price
$59
Max price
$59
Highest 2026 sale
$59
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1964 TOPPS · SGC 1.5

1964 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #150 SGC 1.5

1964 TOPPS #150

Highest 2026 sale: $59 on Aug 22, 2026

Grade
SGC 1.5
Min price
$59
Max price
$59
Highest 2026 sale
$59
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1960 Topps · PSA 1.5

1960 Topps Willie Mays #200 PSA 1.5

1960 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $57 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 1.5
Min price
$57
Max price
$57
Highest 2026 sale
$57
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1961 Topps · PSA 1

1961 Topps Willie Mays #150 PSA 1

1961 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $50 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 1
Min price
$50
Max price
$50
Highest 2026 sale
$50
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1964 Topps · SGC 1

1964 Topps Willie Mays #150 SGC 1

1964 Topps #150

Highest 2026 sale: $45 on Aug 24, 2026

Grade
SGC 1
Min price
$45
Max price
$45
Highest 2026 sale
$45
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1966 TOPPS · PSA 2

1966 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS PSA 2

1966 TOPPS

Highest 2026 sale: $42 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 2
Min price
$42
Max price
$42
Highest 2026 sale
$42
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1971 Topps · SGC 2

1971 Topps WILLIE MAYS #600 SGC 2

1971 Topps #600

Highest 2026 sale: $40 on Sep 8, 2026

Grade
SGC 2
Min price
$40
Max price
$40
Highest 2026 sale
$40
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1967 Topps · SGC 1

1967 Topps Willie Mays #200 SGC 1

1967 Topps #200

Highest 2026 sale: $40 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
SGC 1
Min price
$40
Max price
$40
Highest 2026 sale
$40
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1966 Topps · PSA 1.5

1966 Topps Willie Mays #1 PSA 1.5

1966 Topps #1

Highest 2026 sale: $35 on Sep 1, 2026

Grade
PSA 1.5
Min price
$35
Max price
$35
Highest 2026 sale
$35
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1972 TOPPS · PSA 1

1972 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #49 PSA 1

1972 TOPPS #49

Highest 2026 sale: $30 on Jun 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 1
Min price
$30
Max price
$30
Highest 2026 sale
$30
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details