Sports card comps

Search graded singles, scan PSA grade bands, and review eBay sold history without digging through noisy raw listings.

Tip: include the grader and grade in the search, or use the fields for tighter comps.

100 highest-value 2026 card results eBay sold-history lookup is unavailable; showing local database results only.
Any graderAny gradeNo minNo max
Playerpeyton manningModebroad player scan

Card show read

Fast buying context from the sold history below.

Buy target$4770% of median comp
Median comp$67500 sold comps
Last 3 avg$134Recent tape
LiquidityLiquid451 in 30d · 500 in 90d
FreshnessLatest 1d agoLatest $110
RiskWide spread$1 to $7,500

eBay sold history

Public sold-listing history with direct links to the original eBay listings.

SalePriceDateVenueType
Topps 2010 Draft Picks Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Football Card$1Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
2001 Upper Deck Vintage #70 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts MINT NO RESERVE!$1Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks - Season Ticket Peyton Manning #80$1Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
2003 Topps Chrome #RB22 Peyton Manning FOOTBALL Indianapolis Colts$2Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Fleer E-X Peyton Manning #13 E-Xplosive Insert Colts$2Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
2022 Panini Donruss - Press Proof Premium Gold Holo Peyton Manning Colts$2Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2025 Panini Prizm Draft Picks No. 195 Prizms Gold Ice$2Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2025 Panini Prizm Draft Picks No. 195 Prizms Gold Ice$2Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Donruss Football Premium Gold Press Proof #148 Peyton Manning Colts$2Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Bowman #70 Peyton Manning Interstate E1$3Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
2022 Panini Donruss - Press Proof Premium Gold Holo Peyton Manning Colts$3Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2022 Donruss Premium GOLD Press Proof #57 Indianapolis Colts💥$3Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
2022 Panini Donruss - Press Proof Premium Gold Holo Peyton Manning Colts$3Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Topps Chrome Heroes Peyton Manning 🔥Johnny Unitas #TC1 Colts Hall Of Famer$3Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Bowman Interstate #70 Peyton Manning - FB$3Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2022 Donruss Premium GOLD Press Proof #57 Indianapolis Colts💥$3Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2002 Topps Chrome Own The Game Indianapolis Colts #OG2 - OTG2$4Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Bowman Peyton Manning Colts Early Risers Silver Holofoil Insert Card #U2$5Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Omega Peyton Manning #101 Rookie Card - Indianapolis Colts$5Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #OG2 Indianapolis Colts Own the Game$5Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
Donruss 2005 Throwback Threads Peyton Manning Colts #65 PSA 8$5Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2010 Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Indianapolis Colts Insert$5Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Fleer 1998 Tradition Rookie Sensations Peyton Manning #9 RS RC Colts$6Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning - Colts - 1999 Topps - Season's Best - Rocket Launchers - # SB10$6Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Score PEYTON MANNING Rookie #233 (RC) Indianapolis Colts$6Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Panini 2025 Rookies & Stars Peyton Manning Colts Royalty MEM #R-PMG$6Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
Upper Deck 2009 First Edition Bombs Away! Insert Peyton Manning Colts #BA-12$6Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 TOPPS PEYTON MANNING 3000 YARD CLUB #AM19 COLTS HOF$8Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Playoff Absolute Peyton Manning #68 Colts SGC 8.5$9Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Donruss Preferred #78 Peyton Manning Colts HOF BGS 9$9Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning - 1999 UD Ionix - Power F/X - #P1 - Colts PSA 8$10Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Upper Deck - Peyton Manning #88 PSA 8 NM-MT 2nd year$10Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
2001 Playoff Preferred - Peyton Manning #15 PSA 6$10Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1999 Topps Chrome 3000 Yard Club Insert Peyton Manning Colts #AE19$10Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Mosaic Football Peyton Manning Man of the Year Mosaic Prizm 263 SGC 10$10Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
2019 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning Silver #142 BGS 9 Indianapolis Colts DS9$12Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
2021 Donruss Premium Stock Press Proof Gold Peyton Manning #148 No Helmet Colts$12Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Peyton Manning #300 SGC 9 MINT$13Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Prestige Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 Bronze Rookie (RC) Colts$13Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Pre-season picks P18 Psa$13Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Prestige - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 (RC)$13Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Upper Deck Victory - Peyton Manning #107 - PSA 9 MINT$14Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING #3 Lettermen$14Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
2006 DONRUSS THREADS #51 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9 Stay in the know. Follow us on eBay$15Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
2005 TOPPS TURN BACK THE CLOCK #5 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9 Expert eBay listing since 2003:Consign your best today!$15Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Stadium Club Peyton Manning RC #195 Rookie Colts HOF$15Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
2014 Upper Deck SPX #1 Peyton Manning PSA 9 Tennessee$15Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Fleer Ultra- Peyton Manning Colts #15G Gold Medallion Edition SGC 7 NM$15Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$15Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC Indianapolis Colts (some snowy areas)$15Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning RC #360 Draft Picks Indianapolis Colts (B)$15Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Upper Deck Quarterback Class Peyton Manning PSA 9 Colts Broncos$15Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Collectors Edge Odyssey Peyton Manning Ind Colts Card #66 PSA 8 NM-MT HOF$16Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated$16Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING🔥1999 Bowman Chrome #70 PSA 9 MT🔥Colts$17Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 TOPPS CHROME #16 PEYTON MANNING PSA 8$17Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2010 Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Rookie Base Indianapolis Colts$18Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Upper Deck 2006 SPx Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #37 PSA 9$18Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts$18Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
2011 Topps Peyton Manning #300 Colts SGC 10$18Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING Colts 1998 Draft Pick Throwback FEEL the GAME Card - GEM-MINT 10$19Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Aurora Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Rookie RC #71 PSA 8$19Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
2005 Topps #203 Peyton Manning PSA 9 Mint$20Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning #120 Rookie RC PSA 7$20Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Omega #101 Peyton Manning PSA 8$20Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
2002 DONRUSS GRIDIRON KINGS #35 PEYTON MANNING HOF POP 3 PSA 9 New cards listed daily! Check back often!$20Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Row 3 Rookie RC #3 BGS 8.5 NM-MT+ Colts$20Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
2006 UPPER DECK #82 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF POP 6 PSA 9 Over 20 years of trusted service on eBay. Shop today!$20Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 TOPPS STARS STARCARDS 3 STAR #23 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9 Set builders paradise - improve your registry!$20Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Season Opener Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 Rookie Card - Colts$20Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning RC #360 Draft Picks Indianapolis Colts (A)$20Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
2006 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #181 PSA 9 Mint Colts$20Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - BGS 9 Peyton Manning #135 Top Rookie (RC)$20Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
Score 1998 Peyton Manning #233 Rookie PSA MINSIZERQ Indianapolis Colts$20Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #BC171 PSA 9 MINT$20Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Panini 2022 Donruss Peyton Manning #57 Press Proof Premium Gold Colts BGS 9.5$20Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Season Opener - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 (RC)$20Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning Prime Rookies PSA 8$20Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS GOLD LABEL PEYTON MANNING COLTS RC HOF #20 NM$21Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2002 Bowman Chrome PEYTON MANNING #100 SGC 9 Mint Colts HOF Low Pop$21Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge First Place Peyton Manning Record Setters 1st #135 PSA 8$22Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Constant Threat Rookie RC #CT2 Colts BGS 9$22Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
2010 TOPPS #1 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9 Low rates, marketing, expertise, & more: Consign today!$23Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Absolute Retail Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165 Colts PSA 8$23Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Advantage Peyton Manning RC Silver Rookie #189 Colts PSA 8$24Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Interstate Rookie RC #1 Colts$24Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Metal Universe PEYTON MANNING #189 Indianapolis Colts *CT15B$25Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Ud3 #181 PSA 8 Colts Legend$25Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 2022 Panini Mosaic Super Bowl MOSAIC PRIZM NFL Colts SGC 9.5 Mint$25Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
2003 ULTRA #58 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF POP 3 PSA 9 Over 20 years of trusted service on eBay. Shop today!$25Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning 135 RC Rookie PSA 9 Mint$25Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Upper Deck UD3 PEYTON MANNING PSA 8 NM-MT Rookie Card #181 HOF Colts RC$25Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 With Coating PSA 8$25Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$25Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Rookie Card 1998 Aurora Face Mask Cel Fusions #9 RC BGS 8.5$25Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2004 #1 Peyton Manning PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts NFL Football Card$25Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$25Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Fleer Mystique Peyton Manning #30 Colts PSA 8$26Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Absolute Ssd Hobby: #165 Peyton Manning PSA 8 NM-MT Now Actively Accepting$28Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning #3 Row 3 SGC 9 HOF Rookie Indianapolis Colts$29Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Revolution Showstoppers #16 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie RC BGS 8$29Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Season Opener - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 (RC)$29Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best Honor Roll Insert PSA 9 #H1 Colts NFL$30Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collectors Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 9$30Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Season Opener Draft Picks #1 (RC)$30Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2018 PANINI DONRUSS #84 PEYTON MANNING HOF PSA 10 Price points for all collectors!$30Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 🌟 2013 Select- Hot Stars 🏈 SGC 💎 10 🏈 POP 6 FIRST YEAR SELECT$30Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 UPPER DECK #79 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10 Stay in the know. Follow us on eBay$30Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Indianapolis Colts Football Card$30Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Row 2 #3 ROOKIE RC PSA 7$30Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 UD Choice #193 Peyton Manning RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT COLTS$30Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Row 3 #3 ROOKIE RC PSA 8$30Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING COLTS 2004 UPPER DECK NFL POWER UP FOOTBALL CARD #40 PSA 9$30Aug 8, 2026eBaySold listing
Fleer 1998 Fleer Ultra Peyton Manning #416 Rookie PSA 8 Indianapolis Colts$30Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Absolute Peyton Manning Shields Die Cut RC Rookie PSA 7$30Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2012 Topps Magic Supernatural Stars Peyton Manning SS-PM Broncos PSA 10$30Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$30Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Stadium Club Peyton Manning 3X3 Luminous #T4A Colts SGC 9$30Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) HOF PSA NM-MT 8$30Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
2010 Topps Prime Peyton Manning #110 PSA 10 Gem Mint$30Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
SkyBox 1998 EX 2001 Peyton Manning Rookie #54 Indianapolis Colts Base$30Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$30Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 10 2010 Topps - Peyton Manning #144$31Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning 360 (RC) Indianapolis Colts NFL SEE PHOTOS$32Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
2005 TOPPS #332 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10$33Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Peyton Manning #360 Draft Picks Indianapolis Colts Football Card$33Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
2004 TOPPS #294 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10 Set builders paradise - improve your registry!$35Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2011 Topps Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #368 (HOF) PSA 10 (126778850)$35Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2010 Peyton Manning Draft Picks #360 Indianapolis Colts RC HOF$35Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
2005 UPPER DECK ROOKIE DEBUT #41 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10 New cards listed daily! Check back often!$35Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Ultra Peyton Manning Rookie #201 BGS 8 HOF Indianapolis Colts 🔥 🔥 🔥$35Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 FINEST #121 PEYTON MANNING RC COLTS HOF PSA 8 Fresh grade🔥$35Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 Topps All-Pro Peyton Manning #405 (HOF) PSA 10 (27138940)$35Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
2025 Panini Donruss - All-Time Gridiron Kings Peyton Manning #ATGK-PMG Psa 10$35Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
Upper Deck 2000 UD Ionix Super Trio Peyton Manning #ST1 PSA 9 Colts$35Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Absolute Peyton Manning Retail PSA 9 Rookie$35Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Fleer 1998 Ultra Peyton Manning Rookie #201 Indianapolis Colts PSA 8$35Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
2013 Panini Score Peyton Manning #276 Denver Broncos PSA 10$35Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1999 Stadium Club Peyton Manning Colts 3x3 Insert #T4A$35Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Football #360 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie RC$35Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Bowman Chrome 112 Peyton Manning PSA 9 HOF$35Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
Pacific 1998 Crown Royale Peyton Manning Colts RC Base #54 PSA 8$35Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 SkyBox Premium #231 Peyton Manning BGS 8.5 ROOKIE RC$35Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 8$37Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo$37Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Fleer 2000 Tradition of Excellence Peyton Manning Colts #15TE PSA 10 Insert$37Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate #1 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie Card HOF$38Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE PEYTON MANNING #1 ROOKIE CARD HOF INDIANAPOLIS COLTS$40Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 10 - 2000 Collector's Edge Supreme #59 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts HOF$40Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Ultra Caught In The Draft #4 Peyton Manning Rookie Card BGS 9 Mint HOF$40Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 8 NM-MT 1998 Ultra Peyton Manning #201 Rookie RC$40Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Peyton Manning Draft Picks Insert #360 Indianapolis Colts$40Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 Interstate Rookie$40Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2001 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #67 Colts BGS 9.5$40Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Rookie RC #3 Row 2 SGC 8.5 Colts HOF$40Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Season Opener PEYTON MANNING Colts HOF Rookie RC #1 NM Mint SGC 8.5$40Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Rookie Row 3 BGS 9 MINT IND Colts DEN Broncos$40Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning #16 1st Place Successors PSA 9 Mint Rookie$40Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 U.D. IONIX #23 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10 eBay’s best selection of sports cards is always at 4SC$40Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
Playoff 1998 Absolute Retail Peyton Manning RC #165 Indianapolis Colts BGS 9$40Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2009 Peyton Manning #10 Indianapolis Colts PSA 9$40Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$40Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Ultra Peyton Manning Caught in the Draft RC PSA 9$40Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Prestige Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts$40Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts$41Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Topps 2007 Own the Game #PM2 Insert PSA 10 Football Colts$42Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 METAL UNIVERSE #189 PEYTON MANNING RC COLTS HOF PSA 8 Get unbeatable industry-low consignment rates at 4SC!$42Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Upper Deck Encore - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 8$43Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$43Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promos Indianapolis Colts RC Rookie BGS 9.5$43Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowmans Best Peyton Manning Rookie Card PSA Mint9 Indianapolis Colts$43Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
2009 Donruss Gridiron Gear Peyton Manning #73 PSA GEM MINT 10 Indianapolis Colts$43Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
🔥1998 Bowman Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 9 Rookie 🔥 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS BRONCOS$44Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Stadium Club Peyton Manning 3x3 Luminous SGC 9 Mint #T4A Colts HOF$45Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Draft Picks Rookie Card (RC) #360 - (Colts/HOF)$45Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promos Peyton Manning RC Rookie BGS 9.5 GEM$45Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Absolute Peyton Manning RC #165 Football Indianapolis Colts PSA 9$45Aug 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie Card #360 PSA 6$45Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$45Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 RC No Coating PSA 8 NM-MT$45Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Peyton Manning Colts #RN9 Record Numbers PSA Gem Mint 10$45Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC)$45Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Skybox EX Century - Bright Lights Peyton Manning #19 BL Yellow$45Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman #1 Peyton Manning Rookie SGC 9 HOF Indianapolis Colts RC$45Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 Rookie RC HOF 0ls Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service$46Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Row 3 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Rookie Card RC PSA 9$49Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase Row 2 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Rookie Card RC PSA 9$49Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 FINEST W/COATING #121 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 8$49Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning,2014 Topps Chrome Xfractor #42..SGC 10,POP:4$49Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Peyton Manning RC Draft Picks #360 Indianapolis Colts SGC 8.5$49Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
2004 DONRUSS CLASSICS #39 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF POP 5 PSA 10 Price points for all collectors!$50Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest PEYTON MANNING Rookie RC #121 - PSA 8 - Indianapolis Colts$50Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Aurora Championship Fever Peyton Manning 22 RC Rookie PSA 9 Mint$50Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best - PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC #BP1$50Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts 🔥$50Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 TOPPS ALL-MATRIX #AM19 PEYTON MANNING HOF PSA 9$50Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2000 Chrome Peyton Manning #16 Indianapolis Colts PSA 9$50Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Bowman Chrome Preview #BCP1 PSA 8 NM-MT Rookie RC$50Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
SkyBox 2000 Peyton Manning Colts The Bomb Insert #7 PSA 9NFL Card$50Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Momentum Retail Peyton Manning 146 Rookie PSA 9 Mint$50Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck Star Rookie #1 PSA 8 RC Colts HOF$50Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Upper Deck Choice Peyton Manning #256 RC BGS 9.5$50Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning Rookie Indianapolis Colts NFL$50Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 NFL Bowman's Best Peyton Manning RC Rookie #112 PSA 9 MINT$50Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning RC #360 PSA 5 Colts$50Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2013 Panini Elite Peyton Manning Portraits Silver #3 Broncos PSA 7$50Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Indianapolis Colts NM$50Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 10 2013 SELECT PEYTON MANNING$50Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1 PSA 8$50Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Topps 1998 Stadium Club #195 Rookie RC PSA 9$50Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Metal Universe Peyton Manning #77 Indianapolis Colts PSA 8.5 NM-MT+$50Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Season Opener Draft Picks Peyton Manning #1 Colts BGS 8.5$50Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
Bowman 1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie #1 Interstate Colts NFL Peyday$50Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
Collector's Edge 1998 Masters Peyton Manning Rookie Masters Preview #RM1 PSA 9$50Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Chrome - All-Etch Peyton Manning #AE19$51Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Playoff 1998 Playoff Prestige Peyton Manning Colts #165 Rookie PSA 9$52Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Row 3 Rookie RC #3 Colts PSA 8$52Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Aurora Championship Fever Peyton Manning #22 Colts Rookie RC PSA 9$53Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Stadium Stars Jumbos Peyton Manning #SS9 BGS 8.5 Rookie RC HOF Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service$54Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Colts #112 RC Base PSA 9$54Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 RC Rookie PSA 8 With Coating Colts$55Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 HOF RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT Colts$55Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2004 Donruss Classics #39 Indianapolis Colts PSA 10 - POP 4$55Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Finest Peyton Manning Colts #121 Rookie RC Base Set PSA 8 no coating$55Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase #3 Peyton Manning Row 3 RC PSA 9 Mint Colts$55Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54 PEYTON MANNING Rookie HOF RC PSA 8 Colts/Broncos GOAT 🔥$55Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #112 Colts BGS 9.5 GEM MINT$56Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Peyton Manning #98 (RC) PSA 9$59Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC). High Grade Achieving. 💎 Gem$59Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman’s Best Peyton Manning Best Performers RC #BP1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts$60Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~RARE 1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE PSA-8 NM-MT HOT NFL ROOKIE RC CARD #1$60Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Topps Gold Label #A12 Peyton Manning After Burners BGS 9.5 Gem$60Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman’s Best Peyton Manning RC #112 PSA 9 MINT HOF Indianapolis Colts$60Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Stadium Club Peyton Manning 3x3 Luminous PSA 9 Mint #T4A Colts HOF$60Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Skybox EX Century - Bright Lights Peyton Manning #19 BL Yellow$60Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Rookie Peyton Manning PSA 9 Mint RC$60Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman PEYTON MANNING Colts Broncos MVP HOF Rookie RC #1 Mint PSA 9$60Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Peyton Manning Metal Universe Rookie Card RC #189 BGS 9 Mint$60Aug 7, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1999 EX Century Bright Lights Yellow Acetate Card 19BL$60Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Rookie 1998 Topps Finest Beckett BGS 9 with Coating$60Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Season’s best Freshly$60Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Peyton Manning #54 PSA 7 Rookie RC HOF 0k2i Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service$60Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Finest Peyton Manning COLTS W/coating Freshly$65Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Finest #121 with Coating Peyton Manning PSA 9 Mint Rookie$65Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
2012 Topps Chrome #161 Peyton Manning Xfractors SGC 10$65Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9$65Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Draft Picks Gold Rookie Card Excellent Condition!$65Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Momentum Rookie RC - Peyton Manning #98 PSA 9 - Colts$65Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning HOF$65Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Action Flats #K5 Peyton Manning Rookie Card - Colts SGC 9 Mint$65Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
2011 TOPPS 1950 BOWMAN #13 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10$69Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Pacific 1998 Revolution Peyton Manning Colts #58 SGC 9 MT$69Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Press Pass Triple Threat #TT2 Peyton Manning Colts Volunteers RC PSA 9$69Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 LEAF ROOKIES & STARS POWER TOOLS #270 PEYTON MANNING RC BGS 9.5$69Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Bowman Reserve #78 - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 10 Gem Mint - Indianapolis COLTS$70Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE PSA 9 BOWMAN HOF INDY COLTS PERFECT CORNERS (#1) RZC$70Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~1998 TOPPS FINEST PSA-9 MINT HOT NFL FOOTBALL ROOKIE RC CARD #121$70Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox Premium PEYTON MANNING #231 ROOKIE Card COLTS HOF PSA 9 MINT$70Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Stars Peyton Manning 23 Starcards 3 Star PSA 10 Gem Mint Low Pop$70Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Peyton Manning Metal Universe Rookie Card RC #189 BGS 9 Mint W/subgrades$70Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox Premium PEYTON MANNING #231 ROOKIE Card COLTS HOF PSA 9 MINT$70Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9$70Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning RC #360 Draft Picks Indianapolis Colts$70Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Gold Label Class 1 Rc #20 PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts$70Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Total TOTAL PRODUCTION #TP1 Colts PSA 10 POP 4$70Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Gold Label Peyton Manning Class 1 #20 Colts PSA 9 Rookie Card$70Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
2001 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #48 Colts BGS 9$70Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF$70Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 TOPPS CHROME #53 PEYTON MANNING COLTS$70Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Leaf Peyton Manning Psa 9$71Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie Card #360 PSA 8 Draft Picks HOF RC Colts$74Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Peyton Manning #98 (RC) PSA 9 MINT$75Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Season Opener Draft Picks Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 9$75Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card HOF 2021$75Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest #121 Peyton Manning RC Rookie PSA 9 Mint$75Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning RC #360 Indianapolis Colts PSA 8$75Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1999 Season's Best Peyton Manning Insert #SB10 Colts PSA 9$75Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning Card 2000 Bowman's Best #17 PSA 10$75Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2003 Record Breakers Peyton Manning #RB22 PSA 10 Colts Football$78Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Action Flats #K5 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 - HOF Colts$80Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 9 Mint Indianapolis Colts HOF$80Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 9 1998 Bowman #1 Peyton Manning Colts HOF RC Rookie MINT$80Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Momentum Retail - Peyton Manning #146 (RC) PSA 9$80Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
2013 Panini Select Peyton Manning #38 PSA 10 GEM MINT Broncos Colts HOF$80Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 2006 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts #8 PSA 10 Gem Mint Card$80Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 2000 FLEER SHOWCASE LICENSE TO SKILL DIE-CUT PSA 10 🔥VERY NICE$85Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman "PEYTON MANNING" Interstate Rookie Card ~ BGS 9 Mint ~ HOF !!!$85Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 RC Rookie PSA 8 Indianapolis Colts HOF$86Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning Colts Rookie Card RC #360 PSA 8$89Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Metal Universe #189 Peyton Manning BGS 9.5 Gem Mint$90Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Draft Picks #360 Football Card$90Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo$95Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 Peyton Manning All-Etch (3000 Yard Club) PSA 9 POP 19$95Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Upper Deck Encore #S8 Peyton Manning Super Powers PSA 9 Rookie RC$95Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 2006 TOPPS FINEST #120 PSA 10$95Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 (RC)$95Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest PEYTON MANNING #121 W/ Coating Rc 💎 PSA 9 Mint$99Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 Finest Rookie PEYTON MANNING Finest Moments Card #VFM-PM - PSA 10 GEM MINT!$100Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Flair Showcase - Peyton Manning #3 Row 3 (RC) Gem Mint BGS 9.5$100Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1999 Topps Finest Prominent Figures Insert Colts PSA 9 NFL!$100Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton manning RC #1 Indianapolis Colts PSA 9 📈$100Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning RC #380 PSA 8 Near Mint Rookie Colts$100Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 FLEER SHOWCASE LICENSE TO SKILL - PEYTON MANNING #3 PSA 10 GEM MT$100Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (ROOKIE CARD) HOF Colts QB$100Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 BOWMAN RESERVE #78 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10 New cards listed daily! Check back often!$100Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning Rookie Card (#165)$100Aug 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome - Peyton Manning #1 Interstate (RC) - SGC 8$100Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - PSA 8$100Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
PSA 10 2014 TOPPS FINEST XFRACTOR PEYTON MANNING$100Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
2002 Topps Peyton Manning MVP Promotion PSA 8 Pop 1 None Higher$109Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome PEYTON MANNING Rookie Card RC SGC 9 MINT #1$110Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - Indianapolis Colts - PSA 8$110Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 SGC 9.5 Mint+ Rookie RC HOF e0h Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service$114Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Season Opener Draft Picks #1 PSA9$115Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Collector's Edge 1998 1st Place Peyton Manning #135 Rookie Base Colts PSA 10$118Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 10 Gem Mint$119Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Ultra Peyton Manning Rookie #416 PSA 9 Colts$120Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning (1999) Bowman Insert #U2 Early Risers PSA 9$120Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Leaf Rookie And Stars Peyton Manning Rc Bgs 9.5+$120Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
2009 Bowman Chrome Refractors #12 Peyton Manning PSA 9$120Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning RC #54 PSA 9 MINT HOF$120Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Draft Picks #360 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts$128Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~1998 BOWMAN #1 PSA-9 MINT$130Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning 135 RC Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint$130Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9$130Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning BGS 9$130Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Stadium Club Football Peyton Manning #195 BGS 9.5$135Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best - Peyton Manning #112 Rookie (RC) SGC 10 Colts Broncos HOF$135Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 TOPPS SEASON OPENER SGC-9.5 MINT+ NFL ROOKIE RC CARD#1 Colts$139Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Crown Royale Die Cut Peyton Manning #54 RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9$144Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 SKYBOX E-X 2001 PEYTON MANNING STARDATE 2001 #15S , SGC 8.5$145Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Previews Peyton Manning #BCP1 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Rookie RC HOF$145Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Finest #121 Peyton Manning Rookie BGS 9.5$149Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning Psa 9 Mint Rc Rookie Card #1 HoF Low POP$150Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #TC96 XFractor PSA 9 HOF Indianapolis Colts$150Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1 Interstate (RC) BGS 9 (9.5-9-9-9 Subs)$150Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie Card! Hall of Famer! PSA 9 MINT 🔥🔥🔥$150Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF BCCG 10$160Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest - Stadium Stars Peyton Manning #SS9 BGS 8 RARE 1 DAY AUCTION!!$165Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #112 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT$165Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Draft Picks #360 Peyton Manning BGS 9 MINT Beckett$165Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Colts RC BGS 9.5$165Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~1998 COLLECTOR EDGE ROOKIE MASTERS PREVIEW BGS-9.5 GEM-MT RC CARD$170Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC 💎 SGC 9.5 MINT+ 💎 Colts Broncos$170Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 PLAYOFF ABSOLUTE RETAIL #165 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10$170Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC 💎 SGC 9.5 MINT+ 💎 Colts Broncos HOF SB Champ$170Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC)$175Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Bowman's Best 1998 Peyton Manning Best Performers #BP1 PSA 10 Insert$175Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC BGS 9.5 GEM MINT HOF LOW POP!$175Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Panini 2021 Prizm Draft Picks On Campus Peyton Manning OC-PM PSA 9 NCAA$175Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) Colts SGC 10 Gem$175Aug 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF PSA 9 MINT$185Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 SkyBox E-X2001 Peyton Manning #54 RC ROOKIE PSA 9 MINT Indianapolis Colts$185Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Football NFL Indianapolis Colts RC Card #360 PSA 9$185Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 2002 BOWMAN'S BEST GEM MINT PSA 10 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS HOF!!!$190Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Revolution Peyton Manning RC #58 PSA 9 Colts Volunteers$190Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
SkyBox 1998 E-X2001 Peyton Manning Rookie #54 Colts PSA 9$190Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Ultra Peyton Manning Psa 10 - Low Pop$190Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165 Colts HOF$190Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Skybox E-X Century - Peyton Manning #60 - PSA 9 - Only 8$195Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Colts RC Rookie PSA 9$195Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
2011 TOPPS CHROME XFRACTOR #110 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10$200Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Flair Showcase Row 2 Rookie Card$200Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC) Colts Rookie SGC 9.5$200Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 (RC) Colts Rookie SGC 9.5$200Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
2008 FINEST MOMENTS PEYTON MANNING ☆LOW POP☆ INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 10 GEM-MINT$200Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 Rookie Card PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts$200Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) Rookie Colts Vols$200Aug 7, 2026eBaySold listing
2007 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Xfractor PSA 10 Colts$200Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome - Peyton Manning #1 (RC) BGS 9$200Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 Interstate (RC) PSA 9 Mint$200Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 Indianapolis Colts PSA$205Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
FLEER 2002 TRADITION HEADLINERS PEYTON MANNING COLTS #17 PSA 9 POP 4!!!$215Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts Draft Picks RC #165 BGS 8.5$215Aug 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 - Peyton Manning #54 Rookie RC PSA 9 Mint Indianapolis Colts$217Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS DRAFT PICKS #360 PEYTON MANNING BGS 9.5 GEM MINT ROOKIE RC$220Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Rookie #121 Indianapolis Colts CM4$220Aug 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54 Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts - PSA 9$225Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS #360 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9 Mint Colts$225Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 Topps Gallery - Gallery of Heroes Peyton Manning #GH5 PSA 9$230Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 PINNACLE SCORE SHOWCASE ARTIST PROOF RC #PP123 SGC 9 MINT$230Sep 2, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC PSA 10 Colts$230Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts PSA 9$231Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 SKYBOX E-X2001 #54 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9 MINT$235Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Set PSA 10 Football Card 121$238Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS #360 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9$240Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Peyton Manning #54 (RC) - PSA 9 MT$240Sep 1, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1999 Playoff Contenders Season Ticket 💎 PSA 10 💎 POP 9 💎 #104$240Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps PEYTON MANNING Rookie RC #360 PSA 9 MINT CLEAN!$245Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
#2 1998 Topps Finest #121 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT$249Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 Psa 9 Rookie RC HOF Iconic Card Colts 🔥🔥$250Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~RARE (POP 186) BOWMAN'S BEST PSA-10 GEM-MT HOT ROOKIE RC CARD#BP1$250Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning Rookie Colts #165 (RC)$250Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman’s Best Best Performers #BP1 Peyton Manning ROOKIE PSA GEM MINT 10$250Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF PSA 9 MINT$250Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 Rookie RC SGC 10 Gem Indianapolis Colts HOF$255Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC)$258Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 Rookie RC BGS 8.5 NM-MT+ Colts HOF$259Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Finest Peyton Manning #121 No-Protector PSA 10 (RC) Colts$265Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
#4 1998 Topps Finest #121 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT$266Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning 360 CENTERED & HIGH END Rookie PSA 9 ++++ Colts HOF$268Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome - Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 9 OLD LABEL$275Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Ultra Peyton Manning (RC) #201 PSA 10$275Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9 Mint Only 68$280Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts PSA 9$280Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
Bowman 1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 Rookie RC PSA 9 Colts$280Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 ROOKIE RC COLTS$285Sep 8, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 BOWMAN CHROME RC #1 ROOKIE CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS$290Sep 9, 2026eBaySold listing
🔥Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman's Best Rookie #112 Indianapolis Colts PSA 10💎$295Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Peyton Manning Topps #360 Base Rookie RC BGS 9.5 Gem W/Sub Grades$296Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best - Peyton Manning #112 (RC) PSA 10$299Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman's Best - Best Performers Peyton Manning #BP1 (RC) PSA 10$299Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 RC Rookie PSA 8 NM-MT$299Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Collector's Edge Rookie Ink Peyton Manning Colts Autographed Rookie Card$299Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Skybox E-X Century - Bright Lights Peyton Manning #19 BL Yellow PSA 9 rare$299Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Psa 9 Mint HoF Rc Rookie Card #1 Iconic Card$300Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC PSA 10$300Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~1998 STADIUM CLUB PRIME ROOKIES PSA-10 GEM-MT$300Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 ROOKIE RC COLTS$300Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC PSA 10 Colts W/Coating$300Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Peyton Manning ROOKIE Playoff Absolute Draft Picks Diecut #1 PSA 10 Pop 8$300Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing
🔥📈1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts RC Rookie BGS 9.5🔥📈$320Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Ultra Gold Medallion Peyton Manning Rookie #201G PSA 9$320Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) Rookie PSA 8$320Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC PSA 9$325Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie Card RC #1 PSA 9$325Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 Rookie RC #15S Colts PSA 9$328Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate Peyton Manning Psa 9 Mint Rc Rookie Card #1 HoF$350Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC)$350Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN CHROME #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9$350Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Playoff Prestige - Best of Nfl Peyton Manning #23 Die-Cut (RC) BGS 8$375Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Gold Label Class 1 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie RC #20 GEM MT PSA 10$379Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10$380Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie RC #360 Colts SGC 10 98$380Sep 7, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts$380Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2009 Upper Deck Bombs Away! #BA-12 FIRST “KABOOM” PSA 10 POP 17$381Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 PSA 8 RC Rookie Card HOF COLTS$385Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning 20 Gold Label Class 2 Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint Pop 59$390Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 GEM MINT$398Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Leaf R & S Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Mint Rookie Card #233$399Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 low population$399Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
🔥Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman Chrome Rookie RC #1 BGS 9.5 Gem Colts$399Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1999 Peyton Manning 2nd Year PSA 10 PSA 9 Cards$400Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
2014 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning #58 Silver Prizm PSA 10 Broncos 🔥$400Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 SCORE #PP123 ARTIST'S PROOF HOLO ROOKIE RC BGS 9.5 GEM RARE$400Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 10$413Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~1998 TOPPS GOLD LABEL PSA 10 OLD LABEL GEM-MT ROOKIE RC CARD #20$420Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox EX 2001 Peyton Manning Rookie RC Stardate 2001 PSA 9 Mint$450Aug 25, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Season Opener. PSA$465Aug 22, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD COLTS BRONCOS PSA 9 (OC)$475Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) - BGS 9 HIGH Subgrades$499Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING~RARE POP 12~1998 FINEST JUMBO REFRACTORS BGS-9.5 ROOKIE RC CARD#2$500Aug 9, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Peyton Manning #20 (CLASS 1 GOLD LABEL) PSA 10 GEM MINT (ROOKIE CARD)$500Sep 3, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) - Clean$500Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Football Peyton Manning #1 Indianapolis Colts, PSA 10 GEM MINT,(B193)$500Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie Card #165 BGS 9 BECKETT COLTS RC$525Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Peyton Manning State 2001 #15 PSA 9$525Sep 5, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10$525Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Peyton Manning #15S Stardate PSA 9 Mint ROOKIE RC Insert$530Sep 6, 2026eBaySold listing
PEYTON MANNING 1998 BOWMAN ROOKIE INTERSTATE -BGS 9.5 GEM MINT COLTS!!!$554Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 RC Colts PSA 9$560Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning RC #1 Colts HOF BGS 9.5 TRUE GEM+ Rookie$590Aug 11, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) - PSA 9$625Aug 28, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE PSA 10 Colts$625Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome #165 Peyton Manning Rookie Draft Picks PSA 9 - HOT! NFL HOFer!$650Aug 24, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) PSA 9$650Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) PSA 9$650Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie Card PSA 10!!$650Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 RC PSA 9 - Colts$650Aug 13, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9$650Aug 10, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome #165 Peyton Manning Rookie Draft Picks PSA 9$660Aug 20, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165 Colts PSA 9$661Aug 17, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome #165 - Hall of Famer - Peyton Manning Rookie Card PSA MINT 9 !$675Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 Rookie RC HOF PSA 10$685Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Interstate Rookie Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 POP 85!$685Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Pacific Crown Royale Peyton Manning #54 RC PSA 10 GEM MINT Rookie$699Aug 26, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome Rookie - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) PSA 9 Mint$700Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 (RC) PSA 9$700Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10$800Sep 10, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck #1 PSA 10 RC Indianapolis Colts Rookie HOF$885Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chome Peyton Manning #BCP1 PSA 10 GEM MINT Indianapolis Colts (B193)$900Aug 18, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 2004 Topps Draft Picks #25 *Gold Chrome* Rare Beautiful PSA 10$997Aug 19, 2026eBaySold listing
2000 SPx #34 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9 4SC is now accepting consignments at just 5% on$1,000Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck Rookie #1 PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts HOF$1,100Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome #1-Hall of Famer - Peyton Manning Rookie Card PSA 10 GEM MINT$1,275Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
Topps 1998 Peyton Manning #360 Rookie PSA 10$1,350Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie Card PSA 10!!$1,350Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS #360 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10$1,400Aug 27, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome #1 Peyton Manning Colts RC Rookie HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT$1,526Aug 31, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 SCORE SHOWCASE ARTIST'S PROOF #PP123 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10$1,565Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT$1,785Aug 23, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Stardate Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts #15$1,995Aug 30, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Stardate Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts #15$1,995Aug 29, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning #9 Shining Stars Pulsars PSA 9$2,000Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Fleer Brilliants - Shining Stars Peyton Manning #9SS Pulsars BGS 9 (RC)$2,050Aug 21, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Topps Chrome PEYTON MANNING Rookie Card #165 Indianapolis Colts - PSA 10$3,250Aug 14, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10$3,688Aug 16, 2026eBaySold listing
2022 Panini Absolute - Kaboom! Vertical Peyton Manning #K33$3,900Aug 15, 2026eBaySold listing
2022 PANINI ABSOLUTE KABOOM! VERTICAL #K33 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10$5,000Sep 4, 2026eBaySold listing
1998 Skybox Thunder Rave #239 Peyton Manning RC card /150 PSA 10$7,500Aug 12, 2026eBaySold listing

Matched cards

Grouped by slab, with the current observed sale band split into scan-friendly columns.

1998 Skybox · PSA 10

1998 Skybox Thunder Rave #239 PSA 10

1998 Skybox #239

Highest 2026 sale: $7,500 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$7,500
Max price
$7,500
Highest 2026 sale
$7,500
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 TOPPS CHROME · PSA 10

1998 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #165 PSA 10

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165

Highest 2026 sale: $3,688 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$3,688
Max price
$3,688
Highest 2026 sale
$3,688
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Skybox · PSA 10

1998 Skybox Stardate Peyton Manning #15 PSA 10

1998 Skybox #15

Highest 2026 sale: $1,995 on Aug 30, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$1,995
Max price
$1,995
Highest 2026 sale
$1,995
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · BGS 9.5

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 BGS 9.5

1998 Bowman Chrome #1

Highest 2026 sale: $1,500 on May 24, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$350
Max price
$1,500
Highest 2026 sale
$1,500
Sold comps
5 in 2026
Details
1998 · PSA 10

1998 PEYTON MANNING TOPPS CHROME #165 PSA 10

1998 #165

Highest 2026 sale: $1,500 on Apr 5, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$1,500
Max price
$1,500
Highest 2026 sale
$1,500
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 TOPPS · PSA 10

1998 TOPPS PEYTON MANNING #360 PSA 10

1998 TOPPS #360

Highest 2026 sale: $1,400 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$575
Max price
$1,400
Highest 2026 sale
$1,400
Sold comps
4 in 2026
Details
1998 BOWMAN CHROME · PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN CHROME PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN CHROME

Highest 2026 sale: $1,350 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$600
Max price
$1,350
Highest 2026 sale
$1,350
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · PSA 10

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Broncos Colts #1 PSA 10

1998 Bowman Chrome #1

Highest 2026 sale: $1,350 on Aug 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$1,350
Max price
$1,350
Highest 2026 sale
$1,350
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · PSA 10

1998 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning Rookie Card #165 PSA 10

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $1,300 on Mar 24, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$1,300
Max price
$1,300
Highest 2026 sale
$1,300
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · PSA 10

1998 Bowman Chrome of Famer - Peyton Manning #1-Hall PSA 10

1998 Bowman Chrome #1-Hall

Highest 2026 sale: $1,275 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$1,275
Max price
$1,275
Highest 2026 sale
$1,275
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Upper Deck · PSA 10

1998 Upper Deck Peyton Manning #1 PSA 10

1998 Upper Deck #1

Highest 2026 sale: $1,100 on Sep 4, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$885
Max price
$1,100
Highest 2026 sale
$1,100
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 SKYBOX METAL UNIVERSE QUASARS ROOKIE CARD · PSA 10

1998 SKYBOX METAL UNIVERSE QUASARS ROOKIE CARD PEYTON MANNING #1 PSA 10

1998 SKYBOX METAL UNIVERSE QUASARS ROOKIE CARD #1

Highest 2026 sale: $995 on Aug 5, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$995
Max price
$995
Highest 2026 sale
$995
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2004 Upper Deck · BGS 9.5

2004 Upper Deck Foundations Peyton Manning Eli Endorsements Auto #DE-MM BGS 9.5

2004 Upper Deck

Highest 2026 sale: $872 on Mar 7, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$872
Max price
$872
Highest 2026 sale
$872
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE · PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE PEYTON MANNING #1 PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE #1

Highest 2026 sale: $800 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$413
Max price
$800
Highest 2026 sale
$800
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Picks Peyton Manning #165 PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $700 on Aug 19, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$165
Max price
$700
Highest 2026 sale
$700
Sold comps
8 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC · PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts #165 PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165

Highest 2026 sale: $661 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$661
Max price
$661
Highest 2026 sale
$661
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · PSA 10

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning PSA 10

1998 Bowman

Highest 2026 sale: $650 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$380
Max price
$650
Highest 2026 sale
$650
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $650 on Aug 13, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$165
Max price
$650
Highest 2026 sale
$650
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 BOWMAN · PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN PEYTON MANNING #1 PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN #1

Highest 2026 sale: $625 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$525
Max price
$625
Highest 2026 sale
$625
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2013 Topps · BGS 9.5

2013 Topps Supreme Peyton Manning Auto Relics Blue Patch #/25 Broncos BGS 9.5

2013 Topps

Highest 2026 sale: $580 on Apr 6, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$580
Max price
$580
Highest 2026 sale
$580
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #20 PSA 10

1998 Topps #20

Highest 2026 sale: $500 on Sep 3, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$420
Max price
$500
Highest 2026 sale
$500
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
Football · 1998 Topps Football Peyton Manning · PSA 10

1998 Topps Football Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #1 PSA 10

1998 Topps Football Peyton Manning #1

Highest 2026 sale: $500 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$500
Max price
$500
Highest 2026 sale
$500
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · BGS 9

1998 Topps Chrome Picks Peyton Manning #165 BGS 9

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $499 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$199
Max price
$499
Highest 2026 sale
$499
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 SCORE · BGS 9.5

1998 SCORE PEYTON MANNING #PP123 BGS 9.5

1998 SCORE #PP123

Highest 2026 sale: $400 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$400
Max price
$400
Highest 2026 sale
$400
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 10

1998 Topps Label - Peyton Manning #20 PSA 10

1998 Topps #20

Highest 2026 sale: $399 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$380
Max price
$399
Highest 2026 sale
$399
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · PSA 8

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 PSA 8

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $385 on Aug 30, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$299
Max price
$385
Highest 2026 sale
$385
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome #1

Highest 2026 sale: $350 on Aug 19, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$275
Max price
$350
Highest 2026 sale
$350
Sold comps
4 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome #1

Highest 2026 sale: $350 on Aug 30, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$52
Max price
$350
Highest 2026 sale
$350
Sold comps
5 in 2026
Details
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 Rookie RC · PSA 9

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 Rookie RC Colts #15S PSA 9

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 Rookie RC #15S

Highest 2026 sale: $328 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$328
Max price
$328
Highest 2026 sale
$328
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome Draft · PSA 8

1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 PSA 8

1998 Topps Chrome Draft #165

Highest 2026 sale: $320 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$320
Max price
$320
Highest 2026 sale
$320
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 PSA 9

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Aug 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$225
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
6 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Finest · PSA 10

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 PSA 10

1998 Topps Finest #121

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$134
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
22 in 2026
Details
1998 Playoff · PSA 10

1998 Playoff Peyton Manning #1 PSA 10

1998 Playoff #1

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$300
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 STADIUM CLUB · PSA 10

1998 STADIUM CLUB PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

1998 STADIUM CLUB

Highest 2026 sale: $300 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$300
Max price
$300
Highest 2026 sale
$300
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 · PSA 10

1998 Peyton Manning #112 PSA 10

1998 #112

Highest 2026 sale: $295 on Aug 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$180
Max price
$295
Highest 2026 sale
$295
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 · PSA 9

1998 PEYTON MANNING #1 PSA 9

1998 #1

Highest 2026 sale: $290 on Sep 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$70
Max price
$290
Highest 2026 sale
$290
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1

Highest 2026 sale: $280 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$231
Max price
$280
Highest 2026 sale
$280
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Ultra · PSA 10

1998 Ultra Peyton Manning #201 PSA 10

1998 Ultra #201

Highest 2026 sale: $275 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$275
Max price
$275
Highest 2026 sale
$275
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · SGC 10

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1 SGC 10

1998 Bowman #1

Highest 2026 sale: $255 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
SGC 10
Min price
$119
Max price
$255
Highest 2026 sale
$255
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Skybox · PSA 9

1998 Skybox Peyton Manning #54 PSA 9

1998 Skybox #54

Highest 2026 sale: $217 on Sep 6, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$120
Max price
$217
Highest 2026 sale
$217
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Chrome · BGS 8.5

1998 Topps Chrome Picks Peyton Manning #165 BGS 8.5

1998 Topps Chrome #165

Highest 2026 sale: $210 on Aug 3, 2026

Grade
BGS 8.5
Min price
$210
Max price
$210
Highest 2026 sale
$210
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Interstate #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Aug 9, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$80
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning · SGC 9.5

1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning Colts #360 SGC 9.5

1998 Topps - Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Sep 8, 2026

Grade
SGC 9.5
Min price
$200
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman #1

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$120
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · SGC 9.5

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 SGC 9.5

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $200 on Aug 5, 2026

Grade
SGC 9.5
Min price
$170
Max price
$200
Highest 2026 sale
$200
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1999 Skybox · PSA 9

1999 Skybox E-X Century - Peyton Manning #60 PSA 9

1999 Skybox #60

Highest 2026 sale: $195 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$195
Max price
$195
Highest 2026 sale
$195
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning · PSA 9

1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning Colts #360 PSA 9

1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360

Highest 2026 sale: $195 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$195
Max price
$195
Highest 2026 sale
$195
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2000 Ultra · PSA 10

2000 Ultra Peyton Manning PSA 10

2000 Ultra

Highest 2026 sale: $190 on Aug 13, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$190
Max price
$190
Highest 2026 sale
$190
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Pacific · PSA 9

1998 Pacific Revolution Peyton Manning #58 PSA 9

1998 Pacific #58

Highest 2026 sale: $190 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$190
Max price
$190
Highest 2026 sale
$190
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE · BGS 9.5

1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE PEYTON MANNING #1 BGS 9.5

1998 BOWMAN INTERSTATE #1

Highest 2026 sale: $175 on Aug 19, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$153
Max price
$175
Highest 2026 sale
$175
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2021 Panini Prizm Draft · PSA 9

2021 Panini Prizm Draft NCAA PSA 9

2021 Panini Prizm Draft

Highest 2026 sale: $175 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$175
Max price
$175
Highest 2026 sale
$175
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Draft Picks · BGS 9

1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 BGS 9

1998 Topps Draft Picks #360

Highest 2026 sale: $165 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$165
Max price
$165
Highest 2026 sale
$165
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Topps Finest Peyton Manning · BGS 9.5

1998 Topps Topps Finest Peyton Manning Colts #121 BGS 9.5

1998 Topps Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121

Highest 2026 sale: $165 on Aug 13, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$165
Max price
$165
Highest 2026 sale
$165
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Football · 1998 Stadium Club · BGS 9.5

1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning #195 BGS 9.5

1998 Stadium Club #195

Highest 2026 sale: $135 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$135
Max price
$135
Highest 2026 sale
$135
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · BGS 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning BGS 9

1998 Bowman Chrome

Highest 2026 sale: $130 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$130
Max price
$130
Highest 2026 sale
$130
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman #1

Highest 2026 sale: $130 on Aug 24, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$44
Max price
$130
Highest 2026 sale
$130
Sold comps
5 in 2026
Details
1998 Fleer Ultra · SGC 9

1998 Fleer Ultra Medallion Peyton Manning #201G SGC 9

1998 Fleer Ultra #201G

Highest 2026 sale: $118 on Jun 12, 2026

Grade
SGC 9
Min price
$118
Max price
$118
Highest 2026 sale
$118
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome · SGC 9

1998 Bowman Chrome PEYTON MANNING #1 SGC 9

1998 Bowman Chrome #1

Highest 2026 sale: $110 on Sep 10, 2026

Grade
SGC 9
Min price
$75
Max price
$110
Highest 2026 sale
$110
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2002 Topps · PSA 8

2002 Topps Peyton Manning MVP Promotion PSA 8

2002 Topps

Highest 2026 sale: $109 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$109
Max price
$109
Highest 2026 sale
$109
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 8

1998 Topps Picks Peyton Manning #360 PSA 8

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $100 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$60
Max price
$100
Highest 2026 sale
$100
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2014 TOPPS FINEST · PSA 10

2014 TOPPS FINEST PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

2014 TOPPS FINEST

Highest 2026 sale: $100 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$100
Max price
$100
Highest 2026 sale
$100
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 8

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 PSA 8

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $86 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$74
Max price
$86
Highest 2026 sale
$86
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Playoff · PSA 9

1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Peyton Manning #98 PSA 9

1998 Playoff #98

Highest 2026 sale: $75 on Aug 23, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$59
Max price
$75
Highest 2026 sale
$75
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
Football · 1998 TOPPS FINEST · PSA 9

1998 TOPPS FINEST PEYTON MANNING #121 PSA 9

1998 TOPPS FINEST #121

Highest 2026 sale: $75 on Aug 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$48
Max price
$75
Highest 2026 sale
$75
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
1998 Skybox Premium PEYTON MANNING · PSA 9

1998 Skybox Premium PEYTON MANNING COLTS #231 PSA 9

1998 Skybox Premium PEYTON MANNING #231

Highest 2026 sale: $70 on Sep 1, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$70
Max price
$70
Highest 2026 sale
$70
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Metal Universe · BGS 9

1998 Metal Universe Peyton Manning #189 BGS 9

1998 Metal Universe #189

Highest 2026 sale: $70 on Aug 19, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$60
Max price
$70
Highest 2026 sale
$70
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Finest · BGS 9

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning BGS 9

1998 Topps Finest

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 · PSA 9

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 PSA 9

1998 #112

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$55
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning PSA 9

1998 Bowman

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman · PSA 9

1998 Bowman PEYTON MANNING Colts Broncos #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman #1

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 11, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning · SGC 8

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #1 SGC 8

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1

Highest 2026 sale: $60 on Aug 2, 2026

Grade
SGC 8
Min price
$60
Max price
$60
Highest 2026 sale
$60
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Skybox E-X2001 · PSA 8

1998 Skybox E-X2001 PEYTON MANNING #54 PSA 8

1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54

Highest 2026 sale: $55 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$55
Max price
$55
Highest 2026 sale
$55
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Flair · PSA 9

1998 Flair Showcase #3 PSA 9

1998 Flair #3

Highest 2026 sale: $55 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$55
Max price
$55
Highest 2026 sale
$55
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Finest · PSA 8

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 PSA 8

1998 Topps Finest #121

Highest 2026 sale: $55 on Sep 2, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$50
Max price
$55
Highest 2026 sale
$55
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps Finest Stadium · BGS 8.5

1998 Topps Finest Stadium Stars Jumbos Peyton Manning #SS9 BGS 8.5

1998 Topps Finest Stadium #SS9

Highest 2026 sale: $54 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
BGS 8.5
Min price
$54
Max price
$54
Highest 2026 sale
$54
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · BGS 8.5

1998 Topps Colts #1 BGS 8.5

1998 Topps #1

Highest 2026 sale: $50 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
BGS 8.5
Min price
$50
Max price
$50
Highest 2026 sale
$50
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 · PSA 9

1998 Edge #RM1 PSA 9

1998 #RM1

Highest 2026 sale: $50 on Aug 11, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$50
Max price
$50
Highest 2026 sale
$50
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1999 Flair Showcase · PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase PEYTON MANNING #70 PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase #70

Highest 2026 sale: $50 on Aug 27, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$41
Max price
$50
Highest 2026 sale
$50
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · SGC 8.5

1998 Topps Indianapolis Colts #360 SGC 8.5

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $49 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
SGC 8.5
Min price
$49
Max price
$49
Highest 2026 sale
$49
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Topps · PSA 6

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 PSA 6

1998 Topps #360

Highest 2026 sale: $45 on Sep 8, 2026

Grade
PSA 6
Min price
$29
Max price
$45
Highest 2026 sale
$45
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2006 Fleer · PSA 10

2006 Fleer PEYTON MANNING Colts #41 PSA 10

2006 Fleer #41

Highest 2026 sale: $45 on Jul 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$45
Max price
$45
Highest 2026 sale
$45
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 METAL UNIVERSE · PSA 8

1998 METAL UNIVERSE PEYTON MANNING RC COLTS #189 PSA 8

1998 METAL UNIVERSE #189

Highest 2026 sale: $42 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$42
Max price
$42
Highest 2026 sale
$42
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
Football · 2007 · PSA 10

2007 Peyton Manning #PM2 PSA 10

2007 #PM2

Highest 2026 sale: $42 on Aug 16, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$42
Max price
$42
Highest 2026 sale
$42
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning · PSA 9

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Place Successors #16 PSA 9

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning #16

Highest 2026 sale: $40 on Aug 18, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$40
Max price
$40
Highest 2026 sale
$40
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
PSA 8

Peyton Manning PSA 8

Card details will improve as more matched sales are imported.

Highest 2026 sale: $37 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$37
Max price
$37
Highest 2026 sale
$37
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning · PSA 9

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts #1 PSA 9

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning #1

Highest 2026 sale: $35 on Jun 18, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$35
Max price
$35
Highest 2026 sale
$35
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2006 Topps · PSA 10

2006 Topps Peyton Manning All-Pro #288 PSA 10

2006 Topps #288

Highest 2026 sale: $34 on Jun 21, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$28
Max price
$34
Highest 2026 sale
$34
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
2010 Topps · PSA 10

2010 Topps Peyton Manning #144 PSA 10

2010 Topps #144

Highest 2026 sale: $33 on Jul 1, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$31
Max price
$33
Highest 2026 sale
$33
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Flair · SGC 9

1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning #3 SGC 9

1998 Flair #3

Highest 2026 sale: $29 on Aug 14, 2026

Grade
SGC 9
Min price
$29
Max price
$29
Highest 2026 sale
$29
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning · PSA 8

1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning With Coating #1 PSA 8

1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1

Highest 2026 sale: $25 on Aug 13, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$25
Max price
$25
Highest 2026 sale
$25
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Collector's Edge Advantage Peyton Manning RC Silver Rookie · PSA 8

1998 Collector's Edge Advantage Peyton Manning RC Silver Rookie Colts #189 PSA 8

1998 Collector's Edge Advantage Peyton Manning RC Silver Rookie #189

Highest 2026 sale: $24 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$24
Max price
$24
Highest 2026 sale
$24
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 PLAYOFF ABSOLUTE SILVER DIE-CUT ROOKIE · PSA 8

1998 PLAYOFF ABSOLUTE SILVER DIE-CUT ROOKIE PEYTON MANNING #1 PSA 8

1998 PLAYOFF ABSOLUTE SILVER DIE-CUT ROOKIE #1

Highest 2026 sale: $23 on May 29, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$23
Max price
$23
Highest 2026 sale
$23
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Playoff Absolute Retail Peyton Manning Rookie RC · PSA 8

1998 Playoff Absolute Retail Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts #165 PSA 8

1998 Playoff Absolute Retail Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165

Highest 2026 sale: $23 on Aug 15, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$23
Max price
$23
Highest 2026 sale
$23
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2011 TOPPS · PSA 10

2011 TOPPS INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING #368 PSA 10

2011 TOPPS #368

Highest 2026 sale: $22 on Jul 19, 2026

Grade
PSA 10
Min price
$22
Max price
$22
Highest 2026 sale
$22
Sold comps
3 in 2026
Details
2022 Panini Donruss Peyton Manning · BGS 9.5

2022 Panini Donruss Peyton Manning Proof Premium Gold Colts #57 BGS 9.5

2022 Panini Donruss Peyton Manning #57

Highest 2026 sale: $20 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
BGS 9.5
Min price
$20
Max price
$20
Highest 2026 sale
$20
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
1998 Stadium Club · PSA 8

1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning Prime PSA 8

1998 Stadium Club

Highest 2026 sale: $20 on Aug 12, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$20
Max price
$20
Highest 2026 sale
$20
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2006 Bowman Chrome · PSA 9

2006 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #181 PSA 9

2006 Bowman Chrome #181

Highest 2026 sale: $20 on Aug 10, 2026

Grade
PSA 9
Min price
$20
Max price
$20
Highest 2026 sale
$20
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2000 Topps Chrome · PSA 8

2000 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #16 PSA 8

2000 Topps Chrome #16

Highest 2026 sale: $17 on Aug 22, 2026

Grade
PSA 8
Min price
$15
Max price
$17
Highest 2026 sale
$17
Sold comps
2 in 2026
Details
1998 Score · SGC 92

1998 Score Peyton Manning #233 SGC 92

1998 Score #233

Highest 2026 sale: $9 on Jun 20, 2026

Grade
SGC 92
Min price
$9
Max price
$9
Highest 2026 sale
$9
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details
2000 Donruss Preferred · BGS 9

2000 Donruss Preferred Peyton Manning Colts #78 BGS 9

2000 Donruss Preferred #78

Highest 2026 sale: $9 on Aug 17, 2026

Grade
BGS 9
Min price
$9
Max price
$9
Highest 2026 sale
$9
Sold comps
1 in 2026
Details